Policy recommendations

DRAFT DOCUMENT

This document is an UNOFFICIAL DRAFT and should not be considered official policy. Substantial changes may be made before being published as an official policy. Direct any questions to discuss@rai.apache.org.

Policy recommendations for AI-assisted contributions

This page complements the official ASF Generative Tooling Guidance with practical recommendations for contributors who use AI tools when contributing code, documentation, or other material to Apache projects.

Key recommendations

  1. Follow your project's disclosure practices. Check whether the project asks contributors to disclose AI assistance (for example, in pull request descriptions or via optional commit trailers such as Generated-by: or Assisted-by:). Individual PMCs decide what convention, if any, works best for their workflow; Signed-off-by: and Co-authored-by: should remain reserved for humans rather than AI tools.

  2. Verify tool terms are compatible with Apache License 2.0. Check the terms of service for your AI tool. Some tools grant the provider broad rights over your input (your code) and output (the generated code). Make sure these terms do not conflict with contributing under the Apache License 2.0.

  3. Understand that AI-generated-only content may not be copyrightable. Under US law, only natural persons can be authors, so purely AI-generated material may not receive copyright protection. That alone does not rule out contributing it under the ASF Generative Tooling Guidance, though it is still worth keeping in mind for downstream users and across different jurisdictions.

  4. Maintain human oversight and editorial control. You are responsible for what you commit. Review AI-generated code, understand it, and be able to explain what it does.

  5. Be aware of the EU AI Act. If you or your project uses AI in ways that reach EU audiences (e.g., public-facing chatbots, AI-drafted public-interest content), review the transparency obligations under Article 50 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1689. See EU AI Act and copyright for details.

This is guidance, not binding policy

The recommendations on this page are guidance, not binding policy. Individual Apache projects remain self-governing under the Apache Way and may adopt, adapt, or ignore these recommendations as they see fit. The initiative offers these as shared good practices, and projects are encouraged to discuss them on the mailing list.

Cross-reference: all best practices pages

Topic Page
Authoritative ASF legal policy ASF Generative Tooling Guidance
Guidelines for contributing AI-generated code AI-generated code in Apache projects
US copyright law and AI US copyright law and AI
EU AI Act and copyright EU AI Act and copyright
Tool-use risk for AI assistants Tool-use risk for AI assistants

Back to Best practices.